Walking through Walls

Not many of the contributors to Eat theSky, Drink the Ocean had the chance to meet in person and most of the collaborations were via email, phone and skype. One exception was the creators of the magical graphically illustrated story, Anarkali.

In 2013, Indian writer Annie Zaidi attended the Melbourne Writers Festival and between sessions, met up with graphic novelist Mandy Ord at the Moat Cafe.




Moat is in the basement beneath the Wheeler Centre for Books and Ideas. Its thick stone walls shield patrons from the noise of the city so it’s a good place to think your own thoughts – or in this case – share ideas. I dropped by to see how Annie & Mandy were getting along, feeling a little like an anxious matchmaker as I sat down to listen to their conversation.

Both Mandy and Annie generally create contemporary realist work. Annie is one of those multi-talented writers who has tackled every form – she’s a poet, playwright, journalist, filmmaker, short-story writer and a novelist. She’s not conventionally considered a YA author but she had co-authored  The Bad Boys’s Guide to the Good Indian Girla collection of  stories about Indian teenagers navigating the tricky transition into adulthood, and all the editors wanted to see her work in the anthology.

Mandy Ord is a prolific cartoonist and comic book artist whose book Sensitive Creatures was selected for the prestigious White Raven list at the 2012 Bologna Book Fair. Mandy’s dark, urban landscapes and strangely melancholy characters are very Melbourne in their flavour but universal in their emotional depth.

When I joined  Annie and Mandy at their table in Moat Cafe, they were talking about what sort of rules they might break to transform a story from realism to speculative fiction. Annie paused for a moment and rested her hand on the thick wall of the basement cafe. Then she began to tell Mandy the story of Anarkali, of how the great Mughal Emperor Akbar had entombed a beautiful young dancer in the walls of his palace for the crime of loving his son, Prince Salim.

 I saw the excitement in both Annie and Mandy’s faces as they started talking about how a retelling of this story might work, of how they might change Anarkali’s fate. When the drafts of the story tipped into my dropbox and I opened the files my heart began to race.. Annie’s pared back words read like poetry and Mandy’s stark, vivid illustrations gave a boldness to the tale that encapsulated everything I’d hoped for the stories in the anthology.

Mandy Ord & Annie Zaidi discussing their retelling of the story of Anarkali in the Durbar Hall of the Hotel Diggi Palace, ZEE Jaipur Literary Festival, January 2015.

Before working with Annie, Mandy had never been to India and knew few Indian stories. In January, Mandy and Annie were both guests of the ZEE Jaipur Literary Festivalthe largest literary festival in the world that is staged each year in Rajasthan. Before an audience of hundreds of Indian readers, they discussed the genesis of their re-telling of Anarkali in the gorgeous and lavish Durbar Hall of the Hotel Diggi Palace. The Diggi Palace was converted from the home of the royal family of Jaipur to a heritage hotel in 1991. In some ways, the ornate setting is a world away from the Moat Cafe but thanks to the power of the story of Anarkali, the the stones and the stories of the two venues are mysteriously connected. You only have to use your imagination and you can start walking through walls. 


Pie in the Sky

A lot of people have asked me about the strange and evocative title of Eat the Sky, Drink the Ocean  and where it came from. When I mention the Wobblies, most people look mystified. Even if you know who they are, it’s not necessarily easy to see how a collection of YA speculative fiction focussing on young women can connect to a group of rugged labourers form the early 20th Century.

So – some background. The Wobblies was the nickname of the Industrial Workers of the World (IWW), a radical international labour union that was formed in America in 1905. There are dozens of songs associated with the unionists but one of the most famous is Joe Hill’s  The Preacher and the Slave . Written in 1911, Joe Hill’s song became so iconic that a line from the chorus entered popular culture.

You will eat, bye and bye,
In that glorious land above the sky;
Work and pray, live on hay,
You’ll get pie in the sky when you die.

Joe hill002.jpg

Joe Hill – Swedish-American labour activist, song-writer and cartoonist

In the early 20th Century, the unions saw the churches as being inextricably linked to the bosses. Workers had to know their place and not expect too much for themselves or their families.

You can watch plenty of versions of the song on Youtube but  my favourite version is from the album pictured above. 

I came across the song while researching the early 20th century for my novel The Year It All Ended which is set in 1919. Not long after reading about the Wobblies, Anita, Payal and I were bouncing around possible titles for the anthology including  Tomorrow is another Country and Quantum Leap. But I was humming Joe Hill’s song as I worked and thinking about how we were all talking about wanting a world that was out of reach.

Reading about the labour movement of the early 20th Century  led me to think of where women fitted in the fight for fair working conditions and of Chairman Mao’s famous quote that ‘women hold up half the sky’.  So much fantastic progress has been made for working people in Australia but women still earn, on average, 15% less than men for the same work and sadly, the gap has widened in the last decade. If women are holding up half the sky, they are being paid much less for their labours.

Somehow, Joe Hill’s cheekiness took hold and I talked with Payal and Anita about taking down that bit of ‘pie in the sky’ and eating it right now. So Eat the Sky was born as the first half of the working title. Drink the Ocean came a short time later as an extension of the title needing more balance. Later, I realised that I’ve always associated the ocean with mermaids and sea goddesses and that drinking the ocean was a natural expression of the mystery of our connection to the sea and the tides . We also joked that all that kept the Indian and Australian creators apart was a stretch of ocean. Although we only thought of it as a working title to begin with, it provided such direct inspiration to so many of the stories that by the time all the contributors work was submitted, we knew we couldn’t change it. 

Rivers and Oceans

“Women can change better’n a man,” Ma said soothingly. “Woman got all her life in her arms. Man got it all in his head.”

“Man, he lives in jerks-baby born an’ a man dies, an’ that’s a jerk-gets a farm and looses his farm, an’ that’s a jerk. Woman, its all one flow, like a stream, little eddies, little waterfalls, but the river, it goes right on. Woman looks at it like that. We ain’t gonna die out. People is goin’ on-changin’ a little, maybe, but goin’ right on.”
― John SteinbeckThe Grapes of Wrath

When I was a teenager and first read Steinbeck’s American classic I loved it but there were many things in the novel that bewildered and, occasionally, annoyed me. At fifteen, I didn’t feel like my life was a river. It felt more like a pond. And unlike ‘Ma’ and the women of the novel, my life was very much in my head. I didn’t want to stop living in my head just because I was a girl. I wanted to have ‘a life of the mind’ no less than to be in my body. I wanted pie-in-the-sky and the flow of the river. Now, my life is in my arms and yet it is no less in my head. 

This leads me to my excuse for not posting a more specifically focussed blog about Eat the Sky, Drink the Ocean today. It’s been a busy week of family gatherings, of spending time with offspring who have returned home from overseas for brief visits, of admiring babies as they splash in the paddle pool in our back garden and cooking in the heat of a Melbourne summer.  I have been drinking the ocean where those rivers of a woman’s life converge. Tomorrow I’ll scoop a little bit more sky into my lap top for the next post.

February family gathering at our house.

February family gathering at our house this week with our tribe.



Kirsty is an Australian author of books for children and young adults.

“Every adult was once a child and the child inside them never completely disappears.”

Keep in Touch

Upcoming Events

@kirstymurray on Twitter